Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of clinical trials that were included in systematic review

From: The effect of whole egg consumption on weight and body composition in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis of clinical trials

Authors, publication year

Country

Design

Gender

Duration (weeks)

Health status of participants

Type and amount of intervention

Type and amount of control

Reported data and result

Daly et al. 2022 [60]

Australia

Parallel

Male and female

12

Healthy

Intervention 1: 7 whole eggs/week

Intervention 2: 12 whole eggs/week

2 eggs/week

Weight ↔ 

Njike et al. 2021 [61]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

6

MetS

2 eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔ 

WC ↔ 

Keogh et al. 2020 [40]

Australia

Parallel

Male and female

24

Healthy

10 whole eggs/week

breakfast cereal

Weight ↔ 

Maki et al. 2020 [42]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

4

MetS/prediabetes

12 whole eggs/week

energy-matched breakfast meals without eggs contained higher-CHO foods

Weight ↔ 

Marissa DiBella et al. 2020 [35]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

4

MetS

21 whole eggs/week

choline supplements (choline bitartrate, CB)

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔ 

WC ↔ 

Shakoor et al. 2020 [48]

Pakistan

Cross-over

Male and female

5

MetS

14 whole eggs/week

No egg

BMI ↔ 

Aljohi et al. 2019 [32]

USA

Parallel

Male and female

48

Healthy

no more than 2 whole eggs per day, 12 eggs per week and not to go > 2 days without eating eggs

No egg

BMI ↔ 

Fuller et al. 2018 [37]

Australia

Parallel

Male and female

24

Prediabetes/T2D

12 whole eggs/week

 < 2 eggs/week

WC ↔ 

FFM ↔ 

Missimer et al. 2017 [43]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

4

Healthy

12 whole eggs/week

one packet of oatmeal per day

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔ 

WC ↔ 

DiMarco et al. 2017 [36]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

4

Healthy

Intervention 1: 7 whole eggs/week

Intervention 2: 14 whole eggs/week

Intervention 3: 21 whole eggs/week

No egg

BMI ↔ 

WC ↔ 

Fuller et al. 2016 [38]

Australia

Parallel

Male and female

12

Prediabetes/T2D

12 whole eggs/week

less than 2 eggs/wk

Weight ↔ 

WC ↔ 

FFM ↔ 

Njike et al. 2016 [22]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

12

T2D

10–14 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↑

BMI ↑

WC ↔ 

Clayton et al. 2015 [34]

USA

Parallel

Male and female

12

Healthy

egg-based breakfasts (14 whole eggs/week)

bagel-based breakfasts (9-cm-diameter bagel and the selected options)

Weight ↔ 

FFM ↔ 

Katz et al. 2015 [23]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

6

Established CAD

breakfast with 2 eggs daily

(14 whole eggs/week)

a high-carbohydrate breakfast daily

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔ 

Ballesteros et al., 2015 [33]

Mexico

Cross-over

Male and female

5

T2D

7 whole eggs/week

40 g of oatmeal with 2 cups (472 mL) of lactose-free milk/day

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔ 

Bonny Burns-Whitmore et al. 2014 [51]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

8

Healthy

6 whole eggs/week

walnuts (28.4 g, 6x/week)

Weight ↔ 

Khosla et al., 2013 [46]

USA

Parallel

Male and female

14

Healthy

At least 10 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

Putadechakum et al. 2013 [45]

Thailand

Cross-over

Male and female

4

Hyperlipidemic

Intervention 1: 7 whole eggs/week

Intervention 2: 21 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔ 

WC ↔ 

FFM ↔ 

Taweesak Techakriengkrai et al. 2012 [52]

Thailand

Cross-over

Female

4

Hypercholesterolemic

21 whole eggs/week

1 egg/day

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔

Pearce et al. 2011 [44]

Australia

Parallel

Male and female

12

T2D

high-protein high-cholesterol (14 whole eggs/week)

High-protein low-cholesterol (no eggs with 100 g of lean protein, meat, chicken or fish)

Weight ↔ 

Vislocky et al. 2009 [49]

USA

Parallel

Male and female

8

Healthy

12 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

FFM ↔ 

Harman et al. 2008 [50]

UK

Parallel

Male and female

12

Healthy

14 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

Vander Wal et al. 2008 [58]

USA

Parallel

Male and female

8

Healthy

14 whole eggs/week

Bagel breakfast

BMI ↓

Weight ↓

WC ↔ 

14 whole eggs/week + 1000 kcal energy deficit low fat weight loss diet

bagel breakfast + 1000 ca energy deficit low fat weight loss diet

BMI ↓

Weight ↓

WC ↓

Katz et al. 2005 [39]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

6

Healthy

14 whole eggs/week

60 g uncooked whole oats

BMI ↔

Tannock et al. 2005 [53]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

4

Healthy

Intervention 1: 14 whole eggs/week

Intervention 2: 28 whole eggs/week

No eggs

Weight ↔ 

Chakrabarty et al. 2004 [54]

India

Cross-over

Male and female

8

Healthy

7 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔

Chakrabarty et al. 2002 [55]

India

Cross-over

Male and female

8

Healthy

7 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

BMI ↔

Schnohr et al. 1994 [56]

Denmark

Cross-over

Male and female

6

Healthy

14 whole eggs/week

Usual diet

Weight ↔ 

Lehtimaki et al. 1992 [41]

Finland

Parallel

Male and female

3

Healthy

21 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

Edington et al. 1987 [57]

UK

Cross-over

Male and female

8

Group1: healthy

Group 2: hyperlipidemia

7 whole eggs/week

2 eggs/ week

Weight ↔ 

Sacks et al. 1984 [47]

USA

Cross-over

Male and female

3

Healthy

7 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↔ 

Flaim et al. 1981 [59]

USA

Parallel

Male

5

Healthy

28 whole eggs/week

No egg

Weight ↑

  1. BMI Body mass index, FFM Fat-free mass, WC Waist circumference, MetS Metabolic syndrome, T2D Type 2 diabetes, CAD Cardiovascular disease
  2. ↑Significant increasing effect, ↓significant decreasing effect, ↔non-significant effect