Category | Intervention component or delivery approach | Leal-Blanquet et al. [52]a | Lin et al. [53]a | Soeters et al. [60]a | Wilson et al. [70]b | Eschalier et al. [48]a | Bardgett et al. [73] | Barnes et al. [88] | Berg et al. [74] | Bin Sheeha et al. [75] | Causey-Upton and Howell [76] | Causey-Upton et al. [89] | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Component: Education topic | Knee joint anatomy | O | V | V | |||||||||
Osteoarthritis | O | ||||||||||||
Alternative treatment options to TKR | O | ||||||||||||
Joint replacements in younger people | |||||||||||||
Pre-op exercise/purpose of pre-op rehabilitation | O | V | |||||||||||
Patient active involvement in their own management | O | V | |||||||||||
Goal setting | O | ||||||||||||
Obtaining/using walking aids and other equipment | O | V | |||||||||||
Making home preparations | O | V | V | V | |||||||||
Arranging social support | V | ||||||||||||
Transport | V | ||||||||||||
What to expect during the hospital stay | O | O | V | Vc | V | ||||||||
TKR surgical procedure | O | OV | V | V | |||||||||
Risks of TKR surgery | V | Vc | |||||||||||
Precautions | O | O | O | O | V | ||||||||
Pain expectations | O | V | |||||||||||
Discharge instructions/what to expect following discharge | O | O | O | ||||||||||
Recovery expectations | O | O | V | V | V | ||||||||
Pain management | O | O | O | V | |||||||||
Asking for antiemetics | O | ||||||||||||
Edema management | V | ||||||||||||
Wound healing | V | ||||||||||||
Rehabilitation | O | O | O | V | V | V | |||||||
Alternative and supplementary rehabilitation options | |||||||||||||
Addressing sleep difficulties | V | ||||||||||||
Returning to daily activities | O | O | O | V | V | V | |||||||
Returning to sports | O | ||||||||||||
Returning to work | O | V | |||||||||||
Physical activity | O | ||||||||||||
Nutrition | V | ||||||||||||
Comorbidities | V | ||||||||||||
Other patients’ experiences of TKR | O | ||||||||||||
Component: Activity/ opportunity | Allow participation of a relative or other support | V | V | ||||||||||
Combination of theory and active participation | |||||||||||||
Asking/addressing questions | O | O | O | V | V | ||||||||
Practicing transfers, stairs, post-op exercises and/or mobilizing with or without aids | O | ||||||||||||
Goal setting | O | ||||||||||||
Documentation of concerns, strategies and questions | O | ||||||||||||
Provider | Multidisciplinary team | V | |||||||||||
Researcher(s) | O | ||||||||||||
Orthopaedic surgeon | V | V | |||||||||||
Physician assistant | V | ||||||||||||
Nurse/nurse practitioner | O | O | V | ||||||||||
Physical therapist/physiotherapist | O | V | |||||||||||
Occupational therapist | V | ||||||||||||
Case manager | V | V | |||||||||||
Social worker | V | V | |||||||||||
Previous patients | V | ||||||||||||
Pain management provider | V | ||||||||||||
Home healthcare provider | V | ||||||||||||
Dietetics | V | ||||||||||||
Anesthetist | V | ||||||||||||
Pharmacist | V | ||||||||||||
Diabetes educator | V | ||||||||||||
Hospital concierge | V | ||||||||||||
Translator | V | ||||||||||||
Delivery mode: Format | Single format | O | V | ||||||||||
>1 format | O | O | O | O | V | ||||||||
Individual | O | O | V | ||||||||||
Group | V | ||||||||||||
Face-to-face/visit/session | O | O | O | O | |||||||||
Verbal | V | ||||||||||||
Booklet/other written paper format | O | O | O | V | V | ||||||||
Video/DVD | O | O | V | V | |||||||||
Website/mobile health/other electronic format | O | V | |||||||||||
Virtual reality | |||||||||||||
Telecommunication | O | ||||||||||||
PowerPoint presentation | V | ||||||||||||
Workbook | V | ||||||||||||
Client demonstration or teach back method | V | ||||||||||||
Healthcare provider demonstration | V | ||||||||||||
Delivery mode: Delivery with other patients | Delivered separately from education delivered to patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery | V | V | ||||||||||
Delivered with patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery | V | ||||||||||||
Setting | Pre-op assessment clinic | O | |||||||||||
Schedule: Number of sessions (contacts with education providers) | 0 sessions | V | |||||||||||
1 session | O | O | O | V | |||||||||
2 sessions | O | V | |||||||||||
3 sessions | V | ||||||||||||
≥5 sessions | V | ||||||||||||
Schedule: Timing of delivery | 1 day pre-op | O | |||||||||||
<1 week pre-op | O | V | |||||||||||
~2 weeks pre-op | O | V | |||||||||||
3 weeks pre-op | V | ||||||||||||
~4 weeks pre-op | O | V | |||||||||||
≤4 weeks pre-op | O | ||||||||||||
4–6 weeks pre-op | O | ||||||||||||
6 or ≥8 weeks pre-op | V | ||||||||||||
Immediately after listing for surgery | |||||||||||||
Far in advance of surgery | V | ||||||||||||
Close to surgery | V | ||||||||||||
On the same day as other appointments, e.g., pre-op assessment or physician appointments | O | O | O | O | V | ||||||||
Intensity: Duration of sessions (contacts with education providers) | <15, 15–29 or 30–59 min session | V | |||||||||||
~20–30 min session | O | ||||||||||||
~45 min session, including watching a 10-min DVD twice | O | ||||||||||||
1 to <1.5, 1.5 to <2, 2 to <2.5, 2.5 to <3 or >3 h session | V | ||||||||||||
Intensity: Quantity of information | 12 page booklet | O | |||||||||||
Large volume of information | |||||||||||||
Tailoring | Tailored to patient-specific needs/individualized | O | O | Vc | V | ||||||||
Consistent education for all patients | V | ||||||||||||
Lateralized (right versus left) | O | ||||||||||||
Tailored to patients undergoing TKR | O |
Category | Intervention component or delivery approach | Eschalier et al. [91] | Goldsmith et al. [80] | Høvik et al. [81] | Huber et al. [92] | Sharif et al. [84] | Smith et al. [85] | Snowden et al. [86] | SooHoo et al. [94] | Specht et al. [87] | Westby et al. [30] | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Component: Education topic | Knee joint anatomy | V | V | ||||||||||
Osteoarthritis | V | ||||||||||||
Alternative treatment options to TKR | V | V | |||||||||||
Joint replacements in younger people | Vc | ||||||||||||
Pre-op exercise/purpose of pre-op rehabilitation | |||||||||||||
Patient active involvement in their own management | |||||||||||||
Goal setting | |||||||||||||
Obtaining/using walking aids and other equipment | V | V | V | ||||||||||
Making home preparations | Vc | V | V | ||||||||||
Arranging social support | Vc | ||||||||||||
Transport | V | ||||||||||||
What to expect during the hospital stay | |||||||||||||
TKR surgical procedure | V | V | |||||||||||
Risks of TKR surgery | V | V | V | ||||||||||
Precautions | V | ||||||||||||
Pain expectations | V | V | |||||||||||
Discharge instructions/what to expect following discharge | V | V | |||||||||||
Recovery expectations | Vc | V | V | V | |||||||||
Pain management | V | V | V | ||||||||||
Asking for antiemetics | |||||||||||||
Edema management | |||||||||||||
Wound healing | |||||||||||||
Rehabilitation | Vc | V | V | V | V | V | |||||||
Alternative and supplementary rehabilitation options | V | ||||||||||||
Addressing sleep difficulties | |||||||||||||
Returning to daily activities | V | V | |||||||||||
Returning to sports | V | ||||||||||||
Returning to work | V | ||||||||||||
Physical activity | |||||||||||||
Nutrition | |||||||||||||
Comorbidities | |||||||||||||
Other patients’ experiences of TKR | V | ||||||||||||
Component: Activity/ opportunity | Allow participation of a relative or other support | Vc | V | ||||||||||
Combination of theory and active participation | V | ||||||||||||
Asking/addressing questions | V | V | V | V | V | ||||||||
Practicing transfers, stairs, post-op exercises and/or mobilizing with or without aids | V | ||||||||||||
Goal setting | |||||||||||||
Documentation of concerns, strategies and questions | |||||||||||||
Provider | Multidisciplinary team | V | V | ||||||||||
Researcher(s) | |||||||||||||
Orthopaedic surgeon | V | V | |||||||||||
Physician assistant | |||||||||||||
Nurse/nurse practitioner | V | V | |||||||||||
Physical therapist/physiotherapist | V | ||||||||||||
Occupational therapist | V | ||||||||||||
Case manager | V | ||||||||||||
Social worker | |||||||||||||
Previous patients | V | ||||||||||||
Pain management provider | |||||||||||||
Home healthcare provider | |||||||||||||
Dietetics | |||||||||||||
Anesthetist | |||||||||||||
Pharmacist | |||||||||||||
Diabetes educator | |||||||||||||
Hospital concierge | |||||||||||||
Translator | |||||||||||||
Delivery mode: Format | Single format | ||||||||||||
>1 format | V | ||||||||||||
Individual | Vc | ||||||||||||
Group | V | V | V | ||||||||||
Face-to-face/visit/session | V | V | V | V | |||||||||
Verbal | Vc | V | V | ||||||||||
Booklet/other written paper format | V | V | V | V | V | V | V | ||||||
Video/DVD | V | V | V | ||||||||||
Website/mobile health/other electronic format | V | V | |||||||||||
Virtual reality | V | ||||||||||||
Telecommunication | V | V | |||||||||||
PowerPoint presentation | V | ||||||||||||
Workbook | |||||||||||||
Client demonstration or teach back method | |||||||||||||
Healthcare provider demonstration | |||||||||||||
Delivery mode: Delivery with other patients | Delivered separately from education delivered to patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery | ||||||||||||
Delivered with patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery | V | ||||||||||||
Setting | Pre-op assessment clinic | V | |||||||||||
Schedule: Number of sessions (contacts with education providers) | 0 sessions | ||||||||||||
1 session | |||||||||||||
2 sessions | |||||||||||||
3 sessions | V | ||||||||||||
≥5 sessions | |||||||||||||
Schedule: Timing of delivery | 1 day pre-op | ||||||||||||
<1 week pre-op | |||||||||||||
~2 weeks pre-op | |||||||||||||
3 weeks pre-op | |||||||||||||
~4 weeks pre-op | |||||||||||||
≤4 weeks pre-op | |||||||||||||
4–6 weeks pre-op | |||||||||||||
6 or ≥8 weeks pre-op | |||||||||||||
Immediately after listing for surgery | V | ||||||||||||
Far in advance of surgery | Vc | ||||||||||||
Close to surgery | Vc | ||||||||||||
On the same day as other appointments, e.g., pre-op assessment or physician appointments | |||||||||||||
Intensity: Duration of sessions (contacts with education providers) | <15, 15–29 or 30–59 min session | ||||||||||||
~20–30 min session | |||||||||||||
~45 min session, including watching a 10-min DVD twice | |||||||||||||
1 to <1.5, 1.5 to <2, 2 to <2.5, 2.5 to <3 or >3 h session | |||||||||||||
Intensity: Quantity of information | 12 page booklet | ||||||||||||
Large volume of information | V | V | V | ||||||||||
Tailoring | Tailored to patient-specific needs/individualized | V | V | ||||||||||
Consistent education for all patients | |||||||||||||
Lateralized (right versus left) | |||||||||||||
Tailored to patients undergoing TKR |