Skip to main content

Table 4 Education intervention components and delivery approaches

From: Content and delivery of pre-operative interventions for patients undergoing total knee replacement: a rapid review

Category

Intervention component or delivery approach

Leal-Blanquet et al. [52]a

Lin et al. [53]a

Soeters et al. [60]a

Wilson et al. [70]b

Eschalier et al. [48]a

Bardgett et al. [73]

Barnes et al. [88]

Berg et al. [74]

Bin Sheeha et al. [75]

Causey-Upton and Howell [76]

Causey-Upton et al. [89]

Causey-Upton et al. [77, 90]

Component: Education topic

Knee joint anatomy

    

O

     

V

V

Osteoarthritis

    

O

       

Alternative treatment options to TKR

    

O

       

Joint replacements in younger people

            

Pre-op exercise/purpose of pre-op rehabilitation

    

O

      

V

Patient active involvement in their own management

    

O

   

V

   

Goal setting

  

O

         

Obtaining/using walking aids and other equipment

  

O

        

V

Making home preparations

  

O

 

V

     

V

V

Arranging social support

    

V

       

Transport

           

V

What to expect during the hospital stay

O

 

O

 

V

  

Vc

   

V

TKR surgical procedure

  

O

 

OV

  

V

   

V

Risks of TKR surgery

    

V

  

Vc

    

Precautions

 

O

O

O

O

      

V

Pain expectations

O

          

V

Discharge instructions/what to expect following discharge

O

 

O

 

O

       

Recovery expectations

  

O

 

O

  

V

  

V

V

Pain management

 

O

 

O

O

      

V

Asking for antiemetics

   

O

        

Edema management

           

V

Wound healing

           

V

Rehabilitation

O

 

O

 

O

  

V

  

V

V

Alternative and supplementary rehabilitation options

            

Addressing sleep difficulties

           

V

Returning to daily activities

O

 

O

 

O

 

V

   

V

V

Returning to sports

    

O

       

Returning to work

    

O

V

      

Physical activity

    

O

       

Nutrition

           

V

Comorbidities

           

V

Other patients’ experiences of TKR

O

           

Component: Activity/ opportunity

Allow participation of a relative or other support

         

V

 

V

Combination of theory and active participation

            

Asking/addressing questions

O

 

O

O

     

V

 

V

Practicing transfers, stairs, post-op exercises and/or mobilizing with or without aids

  

O

         

Goal setting

  

O

         

Documentation of concerns, strategies and questions

   

O

        

Provider

Multidisciplinary team

           

V

Researcher(s)

   

O

        

Orthopaedic surgeon

        

V

 

V

 

Physician assistant

          

V

 

Nurse/nurse practitioner

O

O

         

V

Physical therapist/physiotherapist

  

O

        

V

Occupational therapist

           

V

Case manager

          

V

V

Social worker

          

V

V

Previous patients

           

V

Pain management provider

           

V

Home healthcare provider

           

V

Dietetics

           

V

Anesthetist

           

V

Pharmacist

           

V

Diabetes educator

           

V

Hospital concierge

           

V

Translator

           

V

Delivery mode: Format

Single format

    

O

      

V

>1 format

O

O

O

O

       

V

Individual

  

O

O

       

V

Group

           

V

Face-to-face/visit/session

O

O

O

O

        

Verbal

           

V

Booklet/other written paper format

 

O

 

O

O

V

     

V

Video/DVD

O

 

O

       

V

V

Website/mobile health/other electronic format

  

O

        

V

Virtual reality

            

Telecommunication

   

O

        

PowerPoint presentation

           

V

Workbook

           

V

Client demonstration or teach back method

           

V

Healthcare provider demonstration

           

V

Delivery mode: Delivery with other patients

Delivered separately from education delivered to patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery

          

V

V

Delivered with patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery

           

V

Setting

Pre-op assessment clinic

   

O

        

Schedule: Number of sessions (contacts with education providers)

0 sessions

           

V

1 session

O

O

O

        

V

2 sessions

   

O

       

V

3 sessions

           

V

≥5 sessions

           

V

Schedule: Timing of delivery

1 day pre-op

 

O

          

<1 week pre-op

   

O

       

V

~2 weeks pre-op

  

O

        

V

3 weeks pre-op

           

V

~4 weeks pre-op

O

          

V

≤4 weeks pre-op

   

O

        

4–6 weeks pre-op

    

O

       

6 or ≥8 weeks pre-op

           

V

Immediately after listing for surgery

            

Far in advance of surgery

           

V

Close to surgery

           

V

On the same day as other appointments, e.g., pre-op assessment or physician appointments

O

 

O

O

O

      

V

Intensity: Duration of sessions (contacts with education providers)

<15, 15–29 or 30–59 min session

           

V

~20–30 min session

  

O

         

~45 min session, including watching a 10-min DVD twice

O

           

1 to <1.5, 1.5 to <2, 2 to <2.5, 2.5 to <3 or >3 h session

           

V

Intensity: Quantity of information

12 page booklet

   

O

        

Large volume of information

            

Tailoring

Tailored to patient-specific needs/individualized

  

O

O

 

Vc

     

V

Consistent education for all patients

           

V

Lateralized (right versus left)

  

O

         

Tailored to patients undergoing TKR

  

O

         

Category

Intervention component or delivery approach

Drew et al. [78] Judge et al. [79]

Eschalier et al. [91]

Goldsmith et al. [80]

Høvik et al. [81]

Huber et al. [92]

Lucas et al. [82, 83]

Sharif et al. [84]

Smith et al. [85]

Snowden et al. [86]

SooHoo et al. [94]

Specht et al. [87]

Westby et al. [30]

Component: Education topic

Knee joint anatomy

 

V

  

V

       

Osteoarthritis

 

V

          

Alternative treatment options to TKR

 

V

       

V

  

Joint replacements in younger people

Vc

           

Pre-op exercise/purpose of pre-op rehabilitation

            

Patient active involvement in their own management

            

Goal setting

            

Obtaining/using walking aids and other equipment

V

    

V

     

V

Making home preparations

Vc

        

V

 

V

Arranging social support

Vc

           

Transport

           

V

What to expect during the hospital stay

            

TKR surgical procedure

 

V

         

V

Risks of TKR surgery

  

V

      

V

 

V

Precautions

 

V

          

Pain expectations

  

V

    

V

    

Discharge instructions/what to expect following discharge

 

V

         

V

Recovery expectations

Vc

 

V

      

V

 

V

Pain management

  

V

    

V

   

V

Asking for antiemetics

            

Edema management

            

Wound healing

            

Rehabilitation

Vc

V

V

 

V

V

     

V

Alternative and supplementary rehabilitation options

  

V

         

Addressing sleep difficulties

            

Returning to daily activities

 

V

  

V

       

Returning to sports

 

V

          

Returning to work

 

V

          

Physical activity

            

Nutrition

            

Comorbidities

            

Other patients’ experiences of TKR

  

V

         

Component: Activity/ opportunity

Allow participation of a relative or other support

          

Vc

V

Combination of theory and active participation

    

V

       

Asking/addressing questions

  

V

 

V

 

V

   

V

V

Practicing transfers, stairs, post-op exercises and/or mobilizing with or without aids

     

V

      

Goal setting

            

Documentation of concerns, strategies and questions

            

Provider

Multidisciplinary team

V

          

V

Researcher(s)

            

Orthopaedic surgeon

  

V

      

V

  

Physician assistant

            

Nurse/nurse practitioner

     

V

   

V

  

Physical therapist/physiotherapist

     

V

      

Occupational therapist

     

V

      

Case manager

         

V

  

Social worker

            

Previous patients

     

V

      

Pain management provider

            

Home healthcare provider

            

Dietetics

            

Anesthetist

            

Pharmacist

            

Diabetes educator

            

Hospital concierge

            

Translator

            

Delivery mode: Format

Single format

            

>1 format

         

V

  

Individual

          

Vc

 

Group

V

  

V

      

V

 

Face-to-face/visit/session

V

 

V

       

V

V

Verbal

Vc

      

V

  

V

 

Booklet/other written paper format

V

V

 

V

V

    

V

V

V

Video/DVD

      

V

  

V

 

V

Website/mobile health/other electronic format

      

V

  

V

  

Virtual reality

      

V

     

Telecommunication

      

V

    

V

PowerPoint presentation

    

V

       

Workbook

            

Client demonstration or teach back method

            

Healthcare provider demonstration

            

Delivery mode: Delivery with other patients

Delivered separately from education delivered to patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery

            

Delivered with patients waiting for other orthopedic surgery

  

V

         

Setting

Pre-op assessment clinic

        

V

   

Schedule: Number of sessions (contacts with education providers)

0 sessions

            

1 session

            

2 sessions

            

3 sessions

    

V

       

≥5 sessions

            

Schedule: Timing of delivery

1 day pre-op

            

<1 week pre-op

            

~2 weeks pre-op

            

3 weeks pre-op

            

~4 weeks pre-op

            

≤4 weeks pre-op

            

4–6 weeks pre-op

            

6 or ≥8 weeks pre-op

            

Immediately after listing for surgery

          

V

 

Far in advance of surgery

Vc

           

Close to surgery

Vc

           

On the same day as other appointments, e.g., pre-op assessment or physician appointments

            

Intensity: Duration of sessions (contacts with education providers)

<15, 15–29 or 30–59 min session

            

~20–30 min session

            

~45 min session, including watching a 10-min DVD twice

            

1 to <1.5, 1.5 to <2, 2 to <2.5, 2.5 to <3 or >3 h session

            

Intensity: Quantity of information

12 page booklet

            

Large volume of information

       

V

V

 

V

 

Tailoring

Tailored to patient-specific needs/individualized

  

V

   

V

     

Consistent education for all patients

            

Lateralized (right versus left)

            

Tailored to patients undergoing TKR

            
  1. DVD audiovisual videodisc, O intervention component/delivery approach included in an intervention investigated in an outcomes study, pre-op pre-operative, TKR total knee replacement, V participants’ experiences/perspectives of the intervention component/delivery approach reported in a views study
  2. a Outcomes study in which a statistically significant difference in favor of the intervention group was identified for at least one outcome at one or more follow-up time points (alpha=0.05)
  3. b Outcomes study in which no statistically significant differences in favor of the intervention group were identified for any outcomes at any follow-up time points (alpha=0.05)
  4. c Finding is from a study with a mixed population and is not supported with evidence specifically for participants who met the review eligibility criteria