Review | Professional background (code used in the quotes) | Knowledge of the clinical area | DTA-related knowledge | Systematic review methods | Academic role within university | Policy- making experience |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Galactomannan detection for invasive aspergillosis in immune-compromized patients | Hematologist (H1) | Yes | Good | Some | Yes | Yes |
 | Hematologist (H2) | Yes | Good | Some | Yes | Yes |
Policy maker (PM1) | No | Some | Good | Yes | Yes | |
Systematic reviewer (SR1) | No | Little | Good | Yes | No | |
Health economist (HE1) | No | Little | Good | No | No | |
Systematic reviewer (SR2) | No | Good | Good | Yes | Yes | |
Physical examination for lumbar radiculopathy due to disc herniation in patients with low back pain | GP (GP1) | Yes | Little | Little | No | No |
GP (GP2) | Yes | Little | Little | No | No | |
Physiotherapist (PH1) | Yes | Little | Good | Yes | No | |
GP (GP3) | Yes | Good | Good | No | Yes | |
Physiotherapist (PH2) | Yes | Good | Good | Yes | Yes | |
Policy maker (PM2) | Yes | Good | Good | Yes | Yes | |
 | Policy maker (PM3) | No | Some | Good | Yes | Yes |
MRI versus CT for detection of acute vascular lesions in patients presenting with stroke symptoms | Radiologist (R1) | Yes | Little | Little | No | No |
Systematic reviewer (SR3) | No | Little | Some | No | No | |
Health economist (HE2) | No | Good | Good | No | Yes | |
Health economist (HE3) | No | Little | Some | No | No | |
Systematic reviewer (SR4) | No | Little | Good | Yes | No | |
Systematic reviewer (SR5) | No | Good | Good | Yes | No | |
Systematic reviewer (SR6) | Yes | Some | Good | Yes | No | |
Policy maker (PM4) | Yes | Good | Good | Yes | Yes |