Skip to main content

Table 2 Quality assessment of studies included in the systematic review by Newcastle-Ottawa Scale

From: The influence of single nucleotide polymorphisms of NOD2 or CD14 on the risk of Mycobacterium tuberculosis diseases: a systematic review

Source

Selection

Comparability

Exposure

Overall scorea

1

2

3

4

5A

5B

6

7

8

 

1

Zhao et al. [25]

*

*

0

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

5

2

Kang et al. [28]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

6

3

Alavi-Naini et al. [26]

*

*

0

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

5

4

Zhao et al. [31]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

6

5

Rosas-Taraco et al. [4]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

6

6

Pacheco et al. [12]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

6

7

Austin et al. [33]

*

*

0

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

5

8

Zheng et al. [23]

*

*

0

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

5

9

Xue et al. [24]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

6

10

Hall et al. [30]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

0

NA

5

11

Pan et al. [32]

*

0

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

5

12

Ayaslioglu et al. [27]

*

*

*

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

6

13

Druszczyñska et al. [29]

*

0

0

0

*

NA

*

*

NA

4

  1. Abbreviations: NA not applicable
  2. Star (*) indicates the score given to the study according to the NOS quality assessment scale
  3. aDetermined by the total number of stars assigned to study: 0–3 stars = poor; 4–6 stars = moderate; ≥7 stars = good quality