Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 1 Studies citing handbooks: handbooks citing studies

From: A comparison of results of empirical studies of supplementary search techniques and recommendations in review methodology handbooks: a methodological review

Study Cochrane (1994) [6] CRD (2008) [7] Campbell (2010) [8] NICE Handbook (2013) [9] Other source
Adams et al. [25] X X X X NR
Armstrong et al. [31] X X X X
Bakkalbasi et al. [16] X X X X NR
Blumle and Antes [32] X X X X
Bramer et al. [24] X X X X
Briscoe [41] X X
Croft [33] X X X X
Eysenbach et al. [45] X** X X X NR
Falagas et al. [23] X X X X NR
Gibson et al. [14] X X X X NR
Glanville et al. [34] X X X X
Glanville et al. [38] X X X X NR
Godin et al. [43] X X X X
Hay et al. [26] X X X X NR
Hetherington et al. [17] X** X X** X Study predates any handbook
Hinde et al. [2] X X X
Hopewell et al. [27] X X X X NR
Jadad et al. [28] X X X X Study predates any handbook
Janssens et al. [20] X X X NR
Jones et al. [40] X X Institute of Medicine
Langham et al. [30] X X X X NR
Levay et al. [1] X X X
Mahood at al. [44] X X X
Mattioli et al. [35] X X X X NR
McManus et al. [6] X X X X NR
Milne and Thorogood [36] X X X X NR
Moher [39] X X X X NR
O’Leary [15] X X X X NR
Papaioannouet al. [3] X X** X X
Reveiz et al.[18] X X X X  
Robinson et al. [21] X X X X NR
Selph et al. [12] X X X Methods Guide for Effectiveness and Comparative Effectiveness Reviews
Stansfield et al. [42] X X Collaboration for Environmental Evidence
Van Enst et al. [39] X X X X
Wright et al. [22] X Institute of Medicine
TOTAL 17 3 3 3 3 other sources
  1. Studies in italics are ones cited by the handbooks identified using the symbol ‘**’ for informing their guidance
  2. NR not reported