Skip to main content

Table 4 Knee study outcomes and their mapping to three core and one optional OMERACT areas/domains

From: Do outcomes reported in randomised controlled trials of joint replacement surgery fulfil the OMERACT 2.0 Filter? A review of the 2008 and 2013 literature

Authors Pathophysiological Life impact Death All 3 core areas reported Resource use/economic impacta
Pain Stiffness Knee stability Knee alignment (clinical) ROM AE Blood loss RSA RMAL Satis Knee QoL General QoL Function Activity levels Mortality   LoI Surgery time No. trays LoS Reop/readmit Cost per patient
Breugem 2008 [47]             
Chaudhary 2008 [48]              
Dutton 2008 [49]              
Findlay 2008 [50]                
Hall 2008 [51]                  
Han 2008 [52]                 
Hansson 2008 [53]                  
Harato 2008 [54]            
Karachalios 2008 [55]              
Ladermann 2008 [56]              
Lionberger 2008 [57]                      
Lozano 2008 [58]                     
Luring 2008 [59]            
Lutzner 2008 [60]                    
Nutton 2008 [61]                
Oberst 2008 [62]                      
Smith 2008 [63]               
Therbo 2008 [64]                 
Wylde 2008 [65]               
Aggarwal 2013 [66]             
Breeman 2013 [67]               
Chareancholvanich 2013 [68]                 
Dennis 2013 [69]                 
Fischer 2013 [70]                 
Hamilton DF 2013a [71]                      
Hamilton DF 2013b [72]                   
Hamilton WG 2013 [73]                    
Jarvis 2013 [74]                      
Joseph 2013 [75]                     
Jung 2013 [76]                      
Nieuwenhuijse 2013 [77]              
Nishizawa 2013 [78]                      
Pandit 2013 [79]              
Radetzki 2013 [80]               
Roh 2013 [81]                      
Song 2013 [82]              
Umrani 2013 [83]                 
Wergrzyn 2013 [84]                  
Yim 2013 [85]                
  1. 9 RCTs had all the three core areas reported
  2. aArea/domain recommended, but not a core area