Skip to main content

Table 1 Studies of hip and knee arthroplasty from 2008 to 2013

From: Do outcomes reported in randomised controlled trials of joint replacement surgery fulfil the OMERACT 2.0 Filter? A review of the 2008 and 2013 literature

Author

Joint

Comparators

Garcia-Rey 2008 [20]

Hip

Ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene liner THR vs. highly cross-linked polyethylene liner THR

Glyn-Jones 2008a [21]

Hip

Highly cross-linked polyethylene liner THR vs. ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene liner THR

Glyn-Jones 2008b [22]

Hip

Highly cross-linked polyethylene liner THR vs. ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene liner THR

Hamadouche 2008 [23]

Hip

Polished femoral stem THR vs. matte femoral stem THR

Lachiewicz 2008 [24]

Hip

Polished femoral stem THR vs. pre-coated femoral stem THR

Macaulay 2008 [25]

Hip

Hemiarthroplasty vs. THR

Meneghini 2008 [26]

Hip

Two incision minimally invasive THR vs. mini-posterior approach THR vs. mini-anterolateral approach THR

Mouzopoulos 2008 [27]

Hip

Hemiarthroplasty vs. THR vs. internal fixation

Pagnano 2008 [28]

Hip

Mini-incision THR vs. two incision THR

Pitto 2008 [29]

Hip

Polyethylene liner THR ceramic liner THR

Barrett 2013 [30]

Hip

Direct anterior approach THR vs. posterolateral approach THR

Bjorgul 2013 [31]

Hip

Metal-on-metal bearing THR vs. metal-on-polyethylene bearing THR vs. ceramic-on-polyethylene bearing THR

Cadossi 2013 [32]

Hip

Hemiarthroplasty vs. polycarbonateurethane acetabular component THR

Desmarchelier 2013 [33]

Hip

Metal-on-metal bearing THR vs. ceramic-on-ceramic bearing THR

Greidanus 2013 [34]

Hip

Minimally invasive anterolateral approach THR vs. minimally invasive direct lateral approach THR vs. minimally invasive posterolateral approach THR

Hedbeck 2013 [35]

Hip

Cemented hemiarthroplasty vs. internal fixation

Inngul 2013 [36]

Hip

Unipolar hemiarthroplasty vs. bipolar hemiarthroplasty

Kim 2013 [37]

Hip

Alumina-on-alumina ceramic bearing THR vs. alumina on highly cross-linked polyethylene bearing THR

Landgraeber 2013 [38]

Hip

Minimally invasive THR vs. conventional THR

Munzinger 2013 [39]

Hip

Titanium plasma-sprayed cup THR vs. titanium plasma-sprayed cup with additional hydroxyapatite coating THR

Naudie 2013 [40]

Hip

Sintered bead porous surface shell THR vs. titanium anatomic porous surface THR

Penny 2013 [41]

Hip

Standard THR vs. large head THR vs. resurfacing hip replacement

Smolders 2013 [42]

Hip

Resurfacing hip replacement vs. THR

Stiehler 2013 [43]

Hip

Navigated hip resurfacing vs. conventional hip resurfacing

Venditolli 2013 [44]

Hip

Alumina on alumina vs. metal-on-polyethylene THR

Vidovic 2013 [45]

Hip

Cemented hemiarthroplasty vs. cementless hemiarthroplasty

Zagra 2013 [46]

Hip

28 vs 36 vs. 42 mm bearing THR

Breugem 2008 [47]

Knee

Fixed bearing TKR vs. mobile bearing TKR

Chaudhary 2008 [48]

Knee

Posterior cruciate stabilising TKR vs. posterior cruciate-retaining TKR

Dutton 2008 [49]

Knee

Computer-assisted minimally invasive TKR vs. conventional TKR

Findlay 2008 [50]

Knee

Cemented TKR vs. uncemented TKR

Hall 2008 [51]

Knee

Single radius of curvature femoral component TKR vs. multi-radius of curvature femoral component TKR

Han 2008 [52]

Knee

Minimally invasive TKR vs. conventional TKR

Hansson 2008 [53]

Knee

HA-coated TKR vs. Not HA-coated TKR

Harato 2008 [54]

Knee

Posterior cruciate-retaining TKR vs. Posterior cruciate substituting TKR

Karachalios 2008 [55]

Knee

Mini-mid vastus approach TKR standard approach TKR

Ladermann 2008 [56]

Knee

Fixed bearing TKR vs. mobile bearing TKR

Lionberger 2008 [57]

Knee

Electromagnetic navigation TKR vs. infrared navigation TKR

Lozano 2008 [58]

Knee

Extramedullary tibial guide TKR vs. intramedullary tibial guide TKR

Luring 2008 [59]

Knee

Navigated TKR vs. minimally invasive TKR vs. conventional TKR

Lutzner 2008 [60]

Knee

Navigated TKR vs. conventional TKR

Nutton 2008 [61]

Knee

Standard Nexgen TKR vs. high flexion Nexgen TKR

Oberst 2008 [62]

Knee

Navigated TKR vs. conventional TKR

Smith 2008 [63]

Knee

Patellar resurfacing TKR vs. no patellar resurfacing TKR

Therbo 2008 [64]

Knee

HA coated tibial component TKR vs. no HA on tibial component TKR

Wylde 2008 [65]

Knee

Fixed bearing TKR vs. mobile bearing TKR

Aggarwal 2013 [66]

Knee

Fixed bearing TKR vs. mobile bearing TKR

Breeman 2013 [67]

Knee

Mobile bearing TKR vs. fixed bearing TKR

Chareancholvanich 2013 [68]

Knee

Patient-specific cutting guide TKR vs. conventional instrumentation TKR

Dennis 2013 [69]

Knee

High flexion TKR vs. standard device TKR

Fischer 2013 [70]

Knee

High flexion TKR vs. standard device TKR

Hamilton DF 2013a [71]

Knee

Triathlon TKR vs. Kinemax TKR

Hamilton DF 2013b [72]

Knee

Triathlon TKR vs. Kinemax TKR

Hamilton WG 2013 [73]

Knee

Patient-specific instrumentation TKR vs. traditional instrumentation TKR

Jarvis 2013 [74]

Knee

Standard parapatellar approach TKR vs. mini-parapatellar approach TKR

Joseph 2013 [75]

Knee

Computer navigation TKR vs. no computer navigation TKR

Jung 2013 [76]

Knee

Intramedullary alignment TKR vs. extra-medullary alignment TKR

Nieuwenhuijse 2013 [77]

Knee

LPS-flex mobile TKR vs. LPS-flex-fixed TKR vs. LPS-fixed TKR vs. LPS mobile TKR

Nishizawa 2013 [78]

Knee

Cruciate-retaining TKR vs. posterior stabilised TKR

Pandit 2013 [79]

Knee

Cemented unicompartmental knee replacement vs. cementless unicompartmental knee replacement

Radetzki 2013 [80]

Knee

High-flex NexGen LPS flex mobile bearing TKR vs. NexGen LPS TKR

Roh 2013 [81]

Knee

Patient-specific instruments TKR vs. conventional instruments TKR

Song 2013 [82]

Knee

Robotic-assisted TKR vs. conventional TKR instruments

Umrani 2013 [83]

Knee

Patellar eversion TKR vs. no patellar eversion TKR

Wegrzyn 2013 [84]

Knee

Mini-subvastus approach TKR vs. medial parapatellar approach TKR

Yim 2013 [85]

Knee

Robot-assisted classical alignment TKR vs. robot-assisted anatomical alignment TKR

Fialka 2008 [86]

Shoulder

Has shoulder hemiarthroplasty vs. epoca shoulder hemiarthroplasty

Soliman 2013 [87]

Shoulder

Hemiarthroplasty and tenodesis of the long head of the biceps vs. hemiarthroplasty without tenodesis of the long head of the biceps

Lapner 2013 [88]

Shoulder

Tuberosity osteotomy shoulder replacement vs. subscapularis peel shoulder replacement

Hansen 2013 [89]

Hand

Cemented vs. uncemented cups in total trapeziometacarpal joint prostheses

  1. TKR total knee replacement, THR total hip replacement