Skip to main content

Table 1 Assessment of risk of bias (adapted to Cochrane approach Study Quality Guide [20])

From: Incidence of lower extremity amputation in the diabetic compared to the non-diabetic population: a systematic review protocol

Assessment items

Lower risk of bias

Higher risk of bias

Measurement and definition of outcomes LEA

Precise definition and description of how the LEA were recorded

No definition and description of how the LEA were recorded

Diagnostic criteria of diabetes

Documented by physician (clinical diagnosis, ICD)

Self-reported DM

Statistical methods: IR, CumI, RR

Presented as age-sex adjusted estimates; reported with CI

Crude rates; reported without CI

Time trends

Time trends reported using multivariate regression models

Time trends reported only descriptive

Duration of the observation perioda

5 years and more

Less than 5 years

  1. CI confidence interval, CumI cumulative incidence, DM diabetes mellitus, ICD International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, IR incidence rate, RR relative risk
  2. aRelevant for studies reporting time trend