Table 2 Data extraction template items
Demographics | Quality intervention (TIDieR parameters) | QI method |
|---|---|---|
Author, year, country, surgical speciality | 1. Brief name | 1. Sample size |
2. Why (rationale for intervention) | 2. Baseline measurement | |
3. What (materials used to apply the intervention) | 3. Data collection schedule | |
4. Procedures (processes used in the intervention) | 4. Data analysis (e.g. driver diagrams) | |
5. Who (who delivered the intervention, including level of training) | 5. Data volume/duration (e.g. length of PDSA cycle) | |
6. How (mode of delivery: face to face, internet) | 6. Explicit description of prediction of change | |
7. Where (location: emergency or elective, and primary or secondary care) | 7. Missing data (and reasons given) | |
8. When and how much (duration, dose, intensity) | 8. Description of generalizability | |
9. Tailoring (was the intervention planned to be personalised) | 9. Adverse effects (on health care providers and resource utilisation) | |
10. Modifications (describe what, why, when and how modifications were made) | 10. Presence and type of patient or stakeholder involvement (collaborative or consultative) | |
11. How well (strategies to improve or maintain compliance) | ||
12. How well (outcome of compliance assessment) |